This blog post has been researched, edited, and approved by John Hanning and Brian Wages. Join our newsletter below.
When most business owners hear “R&D tax credit,” they picture white lab coats, scientists, or massive breakthrough inventions. If that doesn’t look like their day-to-day work, they assume the credit doesn’t apply and move on.
That assumption is one of the most expensive misunderstandings in tax planning.
The R&D tax credit is not about flashy innovation or outcomes. It’s about how work gets done. If your team is solving technical problems, testing solutions, or trying to improve how something works, qualifying R&D activity may already be happening inside your business.
This guide breaks down what actually qualifies, using clear language, real-world examples, and the way the IRS evaluates R&D in practice.
What the IRS Really Means by “Qualified Research”
The IRS doesn’t define R&D by industry labels or job titles. Instead, it looks at the nature of the work itself. That evaluation is based on what’s known as the Four-Part Test.
The Four-Part Test (Plain English Explanation)
To qualify for the R&D tax credit, an activity must meet all four of these criteria:
- Permitted purpose: The work must aim to improve function, performance, reliability, or quality. This can apply to products, software, processes, or internal systems.
- Technological in nature: The solution has to rely on engineering, computer science, chemistry, physics, or similar hard sciences. General business strategy doesn’t count.
- Elimination of uncertainty: At the beginning of the project, there must be something you genuinely didn’t know. That uncertainty could be about feasibility, design, or how to achieve the desired result.
- Process of experimentation: The team must evaluate different approaches. This can include testing, modeling, prototyping, trial and error, or iteration.
If all four elements are present, the activity likely qualifies, even if the project never reaches the finish line.
What Doesn’t Automatically Disqualify an Activity
A lot of qualifying work gets dismissed because of common myths. These factors alone do not disqualify R&D:
- The project failed or was abandoned
- The work was done for internal use
- The improvement was incremental rather than revolutionary
- The project involved ongoing refinement
The IRS is focused on technical problem-solving, not whether the result was perfect or publicly visible.
Activities That Commonly Qualify for the R&D Tax Credit
Many businesses are already performing qualifying R&D without realizing it. These activities often show up in everyday operations.
1. Software Development (Custom, Internal, or Client-Facing)
Software development is one of the most frequent sources of R&D credits.
Common qualifying examples include:
- Building new software applications or platforms
- Developing internal tools, dashboards, or automation
- Creating system integrations, APIs, or custom architecture
- Improving performance, scalability, security, or reliability
Internal use software can still qualify when the work involves technical uncertainty and problem-solving. If your team is figuring out how to make something work, not just configuring existing software, that’s often R&D.
2. Process Improvement & Operational Innovation
R&D isn’t limited to products or code. Process improvements can qualify when they require technical analysis.
Examples include:
- Redesigning manufacturing or production workflows
- Improving efficiency, throughput, or consistency
- Reducing waste, defects, or energy usage
- Testing new methods to lower costs or cycle time
When changes require engineering judgment and experimentation, they often meet the definition of qualified research.
3. Product Development & Enhancement
New product development is an obvious example, but many companies miss R&D tied to product improvements.
Qualifying activities can include:
- Developing new product lines or components
- Enhancing durability, reliability, or performance
- Experimenting with materials, formulations, or structures
- Prototyping and testing different designs
A product does not have to be brand new. Incremental improvements still qualify when the technical solution isn’t known upfront.
4. Automation, Engineering, and Systems Design
Automation projects frequently involve R&D, especially when standard solutions don’t fully solve the problem.
Examples include:
- Designing custom automated equipment or machinery
- Engineering robotic systems or controls
- Creating proprietary tooling or fixtures
- Integrating hardware and software into new systems
If your team is engineering solutions rather than installing something off the shelf, there’s a strong chance R&D is involved.
Activities That Often Qualify — But Are Frequently Overlooked
Some of the most valuable R&D credits come from work businesses rarely think to include.
1. Failed or Abandoned Projects
Failure does not disqualify R&D. In fact, it often strengthens the case.
Projects that involve multiple attempted solutions, technical obstacles, and documented testing and iteration can still qualify even if they were ultimately shelved. The credit is based on the effort to resolve uncertainty, not the outcome.
2. Improving Existing Products or Systems
Many businesses assume R&D only applies to new inventions. That’s not true.
Improving existing products or systems can qualify when:
- The solution wasn’t known at the start
- Multiple technical paths were considered
- Engineering or scientific judgment was required
Routine updates don’t count, but meaningful technical improvements often do.
3. Service-Based Businesses and R&D
Service-based companies are one of the most overlooked groups when it comes to R&D eligibility.
Many qualify through:
- Custom software or platform development
- Technical service delivery methods
- Engineering-driven problem-solving for clients
- Proprietary tools, models, or internal systems
Being a service business does not exclude you. What matters is the technical nature of the work.
Activities That Typically Do
Not
Qualify (and Why)
Understanding what doesn’t qualify helps clarify the boundaries.
Routine Maintenance and Cosmetic Changes
These activities usually fall outside R&D:
- Fixing known issues with obvious solutions
- Visual or cosmetic updates
- Data entry or basic configuration
If there’s no technical uncertainty, the work is unlikely to qualify.
Market Research, Sales, and Administrative Tasks
The following activities are generally excluded:
- Sales and marketing efforts
- Market or customer research
- Administrative or management tasks
Even when these tasks support R&D projects, they don’t qualify on their own.
How to Tell If Your Activity Qualifies (Quick Self-Check)
If eligibility still feels unclear, this quick self-check can help.
Questions the IRS Would Ask About Your Work
Consider these questions:
- What technical problem were we trying to solve?
- What was uncertain at the beginning?
- What options or approaches were evaluated?
- How did we test or refine those solutions?
Clear answers usually point to qualifying R&D.
Why Misunderstanding Qualified Activities Costs Businesses Thousands
Many businesses miss out on R&D credits because:
- They believe R&D only applies to major inventions
- Their tax advisor takes an overly narrow view
- They don’t realize internal projects can qualify
Over time, these misunderstandings can add up to significant missed savings.
FAQ: R&D Tax Credit Qualification Questions
Do failed projects qualify for the R&D tax credit?
Yes. If the project involved technical uncertainty and experimentation, failure does not disqualify it.
Does improving existing products count toward R&D?
Yes. Improvements qualify when they require engineering judgment and testing, not routine updates.
Do automation and internal tools qualify for the R&D credit?
Often, yes. Custom automation and internal software development frequently meet R&D requirements.
Do service-based businesses qualify for the R&D tax credit?
Yes. Many service businesses qualify through software development, engineering work, and technical problem-solving.
If You’re Solving Technical Problems, You May Already Qualify
The R&D tax credit is much broader than most businesses expect. It’s designed to reward technical experimentation, not just groundbreaking inventions.
If your team is building software, improving processes, designing systems, or working through engineering challenges, there’s a strong chance you already qualify.
Understanding what counts is often the first step toward capturing credits your business has genuinely earned.
2024 Tax Guide
